Title IX concerns for soccer started a study of all outdoor sports activities. The University had considered expanding existing Lyle Hare Stadium to overlay a soccer field with the existing football field surrounded by a competition track. NCAA standards for soccer require a much wider field than football, so the track was redesigned to be a “broke back’ track in order to work with the new width. This added width, in turn pushed the footprint of the track well into adjoining St. Joe Street which created a new set of costs; moving a major city street into a flood zone, FEMA concerns, relocating utilities, etc.

Additionally, Lyle Hare’s grandstands are roughly 50 years old and meet very few current code, accessibility, or NCAA sport guidelines.

Faced with the cost and down-time issues, we administered a series of on-site design exploration charettes to explore alternatives and the pros and cons of each over thirteen different combinations of options were evaluated. Through a process of elimination, the final solution to the University’s concerns emerged a new football and soccer stadium connected to their Donald E Young Athletic Center. The existing Lyle Hare Stadium will remain for track and field. The end result is two fields instead of one, for the same overall cost, a greater connection of outdoor sports to indoor sports and coaches, plus greatly enhanced team facilities.

Spearfish, SD I N/A